Victoria James Recruitment
Hiring costs 3 min read

Agency fees vs an in house recruiter vs a monthly hiring partner: What does each really cost?

Hannah TillotsonHannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine

For a UK business making six hires at around £40,000 over six months, agency fees at 15–20% would cost £36,000–£48,000. An in house recruiter would cost around £30,000–£45,000 for the same period once costs are included. A monthly hiring partner typically costs a fixed fee well below both. The right choice depends less on price than on how often you hire.

Option 1: Recruitment agencies

Agencies charge a percentage of the new starter's first year salary, usually 15–25%. You only pay when someone starts.

  • Good for: one off or very specialist roles
  • Watch out for: costs that rise with every hire and every pound of salary, and a consultant who starts from scratch on each role

Option 2: An in house recruiter

A full time recruiter typically earns £50,000-£80,000, plus National Insurance, pension, tools and job board costs.

  • Good for: businesses hiring constantly, often 20 or more roles a year
  • Watch out for: a big fixed cost that stays when hiring slows down, and one person covering every type of role

Option 3: A monthly hiring partner

A hiring partner works as your recruitment team for a fixed monthly fee, covering an agreed number of roles. With Hiring Engine, that means everything from the job advert to the offer, plus a bench of candidates for your next roles.

  • Good for: growing businesses hiring around 3 to 25 roles a year
  • Watch out for: paying monthly when you only need one hire. In that case, a one-off fee makes more sense.

Side by side: 6 hires in 6 months at £40,000

Agency (15–20%)In house recruiterHiring Engine
Approximate cost£36,000–£48,000£30,000–£45,000£12,900
Cost changes with salary?YesNoNo
Know your business?RarelyYesYes
Bench for future roles?NoSometimesYes

How to choose

Count your roles. One or two a year: use a one off fee. Three to twenty five: a monthly partner usually wins. More than that: it may be time to build an in house team.

From our work

We recently saved a business over £10,000 on hiring fees by switching over to Hiring Engine. They were hiring 5 people within the next 6 months, rather than paying 15% of each salary they paid £12,000 and all roles were covered and filled.
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine
Hannah Tillotson

Written by

Hannah Tillotson

Co-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine.

Let's talk

Talk to the people who've hired, led and scaled teams themselves. We'll show you what a hiring system built around your goals looks like.