Why a fixed recruitment fee takes the risk out of hiring
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring EngineA fixed recruitment fee removes the risk in hiring because the cost is known before the search starts and doesn't change with salary, seniority or the number of hires. It also changes the recruiter's incentive: when the fee is the same either way, the only way to win is to find someone who fits and stays.
The problem with percentage fees
Most UK agencies charge 15-25% of a new starter's first-year salary. That creates three risks for the business:
- You don't know the cost until the offer is signed. If a strong candidate needs £10,000 more, the fee goes up too.
- The recruiter earns more when you pay more. That's not a comfortable incentive at the offer stage.
- Churn becomes a revenue stream. If a hire leaves, the role gets filled again, often with another fee.
What a fixed fee changes
| Percentage fee | Fixed fee | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost known upfront | No | Yes |
| Rises with salary | Yes | No |
| Recruiter's incentive | Fill fast, fill high | Fill right |
It's fairer for candidates too
A candidate pointed this out to us recently. With a percentage fee, the better someone is paid, the more expensive they are to hire, which can quietly count against strong candidates. A fixed fee removes that penalty, so a business can offer people what they're worth.
What to look for in a fixed fee model
- A clear list of what's included, from advert to offer
- An agreed number of roles, with a fixed price for any extra hires
- A replacement or review process if a hire doesn't work out
- Simple terms after the first period, such as a monthly rolling agreement
From our work
We recently worked with a client who had been charged £21,000 previously with an agency for a senior hire, they had a guarantee of 3 months but the candidate left after 4 months so they were not covered by a replacement, they came to us to save money. We spent time getting to know what they wanted, what went wrong with the other hire and found them somebody within 4 weeks. They paid us £2,150 for that same hire, 12 months later they are still in position. We also placed 3 others alongside this hire within a 6 month period.
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine
Written by
Hannah Tillotson
Co-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine.
