The hidden cost of managers doing the hiring themselves
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring EngineWhen a business says it does its hiring in house to save money, the cost hasn't disappeared. It has moved into the salaries of the managers doing the work. Two heads of department on £75,000 who each spend one day a week on hiring cost a business around £18,000 in salary over six months, before counting the work they didn't get done.
Why "doing it ourselves" feels free
There's no invoice. Nobody signs off a recruitment budget. The job ad goes on a free board, the CVs land in a manager's inbox, and the hiring gets done between meetings.
And often, it works. Managers know their teams better than anyone, and plenty of businesses tell us their best hires came from doing it themselves. That judgement is valuable. The problem is everything around it.
Where the time actually goes
The final interview and decision take a few hours. Everything before it takes days:
- Writing and posting the job advert
- Sifting through dozens or hundreds of applications
- First stage phone calls, most of which go nowhere
- Booking and rebooking interviews
- Chasing candidates who go quiet
- Managing the offer, references and notice periods
For a manager, that's easily a day a week while a role is open. When a business is growing and roles are always open, it becomes a permanent part of the job.
A worked example
Take two heads of department, each on a £75,000 salary. With employer National Insurance and pension, each costs the business roughly £90,000 a year, or about £47 an hour.
If each spends one day a week on hiring for six months, that's 345 hours between them, or roughly £18,000 of senior salary spent on admin.
And that's only the visible part. Those hours came from somewhere: team management, sales, projects, the work they were actually hired to do.
Keep the decision, lose the admin
The answer isn't to take hiring away from managers. It's to take away the 80% that doesn't need them. With a dedicated hiring partner, managers only meet shortlisted candidates who are already right for the role. They still make every final decision, but they get their weeks back.
From our work
We have recently worked with a team whose hiring managers were stretched for time with their standard day to day responsibilities so they couldn’t prioritise hiring but the team were suffering - We helped save them time sourcing, sifting and initial screening and only presented 9/10 this resulted in getting the hires they needed in place within 21 days.
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring EngineWork out your own number
Multiply the number of managers involved in hiring by the hours they spend on it each week, then by their hourly cost. Most businesses are surprised by the answer. Our hidden cost calculator does the sum for you.

Written by
Hannah Tillotson
Co-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine. 17 years in recruitment, including as a hiring manager.
