Victoria James Recruitment
Hiring leaders 2 min read

How to hire your first Head of Marketing

Hannah TillotsonHannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine

To hire your first Head of Marketing, start by deciding whether you need a strategist who can build a function or a hands on marketer who can deliver results now. Most growing businesses need someone who can do both for the first year: set the plan, then roll up their sleeves to execute it while the team grows.

Decide what the role is really for

Before writing a job advert, answer three questions:

  • What does success look like in 12 months? More leads, a stronger brand, a new market, or a working marketing engine?
  • Who will they manage? A team of five needs a leader. A team of none needs a doer.
  • What's the budget? Someone used to spending millions will struggle with a few thousand a month, and vice versa.

Builder or scaler?

BuilderScaler
Best forFirst marketing hire, small or no teamExisting team that needs direction
StrengthsHands on, fast, comfortable with no processStrategy, leadership, systems
RiskMay struggle to step back as the team growsMay struggle without a team to delegate to

Most first hires should be builders with the potential to scale.

What to look for

  • Owned a number. Plenty of people call themselves growth leaders. Look for someone who has been accountable for leads, pipeline or revenue, not someone who ran campaigns underneath a person who did.
  • Experience at your stage. A marketer from a 5,000 person company may not thrive at 50.
  • Range. In a first hire you need someone comfortable across digital, content and brand.
  • Commercial thinking. They should talk about results before tactics.

Questions worth asking at interview

  • "Tell me about a number you were responsible for. How did you move it?"
  • "What would you do in your first 90 days here?"
  • "What did you do yourself, and what did your team do?"

From our work

A growing tech business we work with told us their new marketing hire was the best marketing person they'd ever had. The difference wasn't a bigger search. It was taking the time to understand what they really needed before we looked, and then putting forward people who'd owned results, not just run campaigns
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine
Hannah Tillotson

Written by

Hannah Tillotson

Co-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine.

Let's talk

Talk to the people who've hired, led and scaled teams themselves. We'll show you what a hiring system built around your goals looks like.