Why candidates turn down job offers, and how to stop it
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring EngineMost candidates turn down job offers for reasons that could have been spotted earlier: the salary didn't match what they expected, the process took too long, a counter offer came in, or the role turned out different from what they'd heard. The fix is to find these out before the offer, not after it.
The five most common reasons
- Salary surprises. The number in the offer is the first time either side has been honest about pay.
- A slow process. Good candidates rarely have just one option. Every extra week gives a competitor time to move.
- Counter offers. Their current employer suddenly finds more money once they resign.
- The role has changed. What they were told at the first interview doesn't match the offer.
- A poor experience. Late feedback, rescheduled interviews or no one explaining the next step.
How to prevent each one
| Reason | Prevention |
|---|---|
| Salary | Agree an expected range at the first conversation and check it again before the final interview |
| Slow process | Book every interview stage in advance and give feedback within 48 hours |
| Counter offer | Ask early: "If your employer offered more, would you stay?" and talk through why they want to move |
| Changed role | Write the role down clearly and keep every interviewer saying the same thing |
| Poor experience | Give every candidate a single point of contact who keeps them updated |
Check before you offer
Before making an offer, confirm three things: the salary they'd accept, their notice period, and anything else they're waiting to hear back on. If any answer is unclear, the offer isn't ready.
At Hiring Engine, 96% of our offers are accepted, largely because these conversations happen early, so there are no surprises at the end.
From our work
We recently approached a candidate from one of our clients competitors, they weren’t actively seeking a new role but were open to a conversation, before we even introduced to the client we got the candidate to check their contract for any clauses that may stop them working for a competitor, we also approached them regarding the likelihood of counter offers and helped them through the process before it was even a problem to avoid wasting any ones time.
Hannah TillotsonCo-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine
Written by
Hannah Tillotson
Co-founder, Victoria James Recruitment & Hiring Engine.
